Accounts, orders and returns · Article 2 of 5

Sign-in and passwords: getting customers in without friction

After sign-in, send customers back to where they were. Make a remembered-but-not-signed-in state obvious, say if no account exists when they reset a password, avoid harsh lockouts and needless re-sign-ins, and let customers track an order from the email without signing in.

In this article · 5 tips
  1. Sign-in friction
  2. 1After sign-in, send customers back to where they were
  3. 2Make a "remembered but not signed in" state obvious
  4. 3Tell customers if no account exists when they reset a password
  5. 4Don't lock accounts after a few wrong passwords, and don't make people sign in again without reason
  6. 5Let customers track an order from the email without signing in
  7. FAQ

In short

  • Sign-in is a means to an end. Get customers back to what they were doing.
  • Passwordless sign-in removes most password problems.
  • Tracking an order should never require a password.

Sign-in friction

Sign-in problems are some of the most common customer support issues. Forgotten passwords, accounts that don't exist, lockouts and being sent to the wrong page all end with a frustrated customer.

1After sign-in, send customers back to where they were

After signing in, send customers back to the page they were on.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41
☰STORE⌕👤 Jane🛍2

My account

Signed in from a product page, landed on the dashboard

Orders›

Addresses›

They signed in to save a product and got sent to the dashboard. Now they have to find the product again.

✓ Do this

9:41

Signed in

☰STORE⌕👤 Jane🛍2

Linen shirt

Add to cart
Back on the same product, signed in, ready to continue.

Why it matters

A customer who signs in from a product page or the cart and lands on the account dashboard has to find their way back.

How to do it

  • Return customers to the page they were on after signing in.
  • After a password reset, sign them in and return them too.

On ShopifyCode

Shopify customer account links can include a return URL; check how your theme handles it.

Quick test: Do customers return to where they were after signing in?

2Make a "remembered but not signed in" state obvious

If you greet a remembered customer by name, make it clear they're not signed in yet.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41
☰STORE⌕👤 Hi Jane🛍2

Orders

Please sign in

Password
"Hi Jane" suggests she's signed in, then every click asks for a password.

✓ Do this

9:41
☰STORE⌕👤 Hi Jane🛍2

Hi Jane (not you?)

Sign in to see orders
The greeting says she's remembered, not signed in, with a clear way in.

Why it matters

Some stores greet returning visitors by name without signing them in. Customers then don't understand why they're asked to sign in to see their orders.

How to do it

  • If you show a remembered name, say clearly that they're not signed in: "Hi Ana (not you?) · Sign in to see orders".
  • Ask for sign-in only when needed (orders, saved details).

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shop Pay can recognise returning buyers at checkout; make sure your header doesn't suggest they're signed in when they aren't.

Quick test: Is it clear when a remembered customer isn't actually signed in?

3Tell customers if no account exists when they reset a password

If someone tries to reset a password for an email with no account, tell them.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reset password

Emailjane@email.com

If an account exists, we've sent an email.

No email ever arrives…

The customer checked out as a guest and has no account. They wait for an email that will never come.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reset password

Emailjane@email.com

There's no account for jane@email.com. You may have checked out as a guest.

Create an account
A clear answer and two useful next steps.

Why it matters

Customers who checked out as guests often think they have an account. A reset form that silently "sends" an email that never arrives leaves them waiting.

How to do it

  • If there's no account for that email, say so and offer to create one (balanced against your security needs).
  • Mention that guest orders can be tracked without an account.

On ShopifyBuilt in

With Shopify's passwordless customer accounts, customers enter their email and receive a code, which avoids password resets.

Quick test: Does the password reset tell customers what happened and what to do next?

4Don't lock accounts after a few wrong passwords, and don't make people sign in again without reason

Don't lock accounts after a few wrong passwords. Slow down attempts and offer a sign-in code instead.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Sign in

Password••••••Account locked after 3 attempts. Contact support.
Locked out after three typos. A customer trying to buy now has to email support.

✓ Do this

9:41

Sign in

Password••••••That password doesn't match
Try againEmail me a sign-in code
Another try, or a one-time code by email. Security stays, the sale isn't lost.

Why it matters

Strict lockouts punish customers who mistype on phones, and frequent sign-out forces them to sign in again and again. Both drive support emails.

How to do it

  • Use rate limiting and soft delays instead of quick lockouts.
  • Keep customers signed in for a reasonable time on their own devices.
  • Ask for sign-in again only for sensitive actions (changing email or payment).

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify handles session length and sign-in security for customer accounts.

Quick test: Are customers kept signed in, without harsh lockouts?

5Let customers track an order from the email without signing in

Order emails should link to a tracking page that works without signing in.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Your order has shipped!

Track your order

Sign in to continue

Email
Password
The email's Track button opens a sign-in wall. Guests can't track at all.

✓ Do this

9:41

Your order has shipped!

Track your order

↓ opens directly

Arrives Fri, Nov 21

Order #1042 · On its way

The link opens the order status straight away, for guests and account holders.

Why it matters

The order email is where most customers start tracking. If the tracking link asks for a password, many give up and email support instead.

How to do it

  • Link the shipping and confirmation emails to an order status page that works without sign-in.
  • Ask for sign-in only for actions that need it.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify's order status page link in notification emails works without signing in.

Quick test: Can customers track an order from the email without signing in?

FAQ

Does Shopify have passwordless login?

Yes. Shopify's current customer accounts let customers sign in with a one-time code sent by email.

Sources

Alex Peric

Written by Alex Peric

Conversion designer. I design, redesign and build online stores, product pages and landing pages, A/B test them and show what each change earned. CXL certified in Conversion Optimization and Ecommerce Marketing, and a guest speaker on ecommerce UX at NYU School of Professional Studies.

Let's talk

Let's find out why your visitors aren't buying.

Send me the page. On the call I'll tell you what I'd fix first, what it could move, and whether I'm the right person for it.

Book a call