Cart and checkout · Article 3 of 9

Guest checkout and accounts: don't make shoppers sign up to buy

Offer guest checkout and make it the easiest path. Ask shoppers to create an account after the order, when it's one step and they can see the benefit. Say what an account gives them, keep password rules simple and visible upfront, and let them show the password while typing.

In this article · 5 tips
  1. Why guest checkout matters
  2. 1Let shoppers buy as a guest, and put that path first
  3. 2Offer account creation after the order, not before
  4. 3Say what an account gives the shopper
  5. 4Keep password rules simple and show them upfront
  6. 5Let shoppers show the password they're typing
  7. FAQ

In short

  • Being forced to create an account is one of the most common reasons shoppers abandon checkout.
  • After the order, an account is easy to sell: "Save your details and track this order".
  • Passwordless sign-in (a code by email) removes the password problem entirely.

Why guest checkout matters

Shoppers came to buy, not to join. An account wall in front of checkout asks for a password, an email confirmation and a commitment before they've paid, and many leave. Accounts are still valuable for repeat customers; the trick is asking at the right moment.

1Let shoppers buy as a guest, and put that path first

A required account is one of the top reasons shoppers abandon. Let them buy as a guest, and make that the obvious path.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

STORE

🔒 Secure checkout

Sign in to check out

Emailyou@email.com
Password
Sign in

New here? Create an account

Guest checkout

Sign-in fills the screen. Guest checkout is a small grey line at the bottom, and many shoppers think they must register.

✓ Do this

9:41

STORE

🔒 Secure checkout

Checkout

Continue as guest

or

Sign in for faster checkout

You can create an account after your order

Guest checkout is the first, biggest button. Returning customers can still sign in.

Why it matters

Shoppers who see "Sign in or create an account" as the first checkout step often think they have to, even if a guest option sits below. The guest path must be obvious and first.

How to do it

  • Offer guest checkout on every order.
  • Make "Continue as guest" (or simply the email field) the primary path; offer sign-in as a secondary link.
  • Don't call it something unclear like "New customer"; say "Check out as guest".
  • Let returning customers use express options (wallets, saved details) without a password.

On ShopifyCheckout settings

In Settings › Customer accounts, keep accounts optional. With Shopify's current customer accounts, sign-in is optional and passwordless, and checkout starts with the email field.

Quick test: Can shoppers check out as guests, and is that the most obvious path?

2Offer account creation after the order, not before

Ask for a password after the order, when you already have everything else and the shopper has nothing to lose.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

STORE

🔒 Secure checkout

1Information2Shipping3Payment
Emailjane@email.com
Create password *
Confirm password *
Continue
Password fields in the middle of checkout. It's a hurdle before paying, and a reason to stop.

✓ Do this

9:41

✓ Order #1042 confirmed

Save your details for next time?

PasswordAt least 8 characters
Create account

We'll use the details from this order

After the order: one password field, and the account is ready with everything already filled in.

Why it matters

On the confirmation page the shopper has already given everything an account needs. Creating one is now a single step, and the benefit is concrete: track this order, save these details.

How to do it

  • On the order confirmation page, offer "Save your details for next time" or "Create an account to track this order" with one field or one click.
  • Prefill everything you already have.
  • Don't block the confirmation behind it; keep it optional.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify's customer accounts let buyers sign in with a one-time code by email, so returning customers don't need a password. The order status page links to the account.

Quick test: Is account creation offered after the order, prefilled and optional?

3Say what an account gives the shopper

"Create an account" means nothing until you say what's in it for the shopper.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Create an account

Email
Password
Register
A bare form. Shoppers see more work and more emails, and skip it.

✓ Do this

9:41

Create an account

✓Track every order in one place

✓Check out in one tap next time

✓Start returns without a receipt

Password
Create account
Three concrete benefits above the field. The reason to sign up is clear before the effort.

Why it matters

"Create an account" is a cost unless shoppers see what they get. A short list of real benefits makes the offer worth it.

How to do it

  • List two or three concrete benefits: faster checkout, order tracking, easy returns, saved wishlist, loyalty points.
  • Show them where you ask for an account (confirmation page, account menu).
  • Only list benefits that exist.

On ShopifyTheme setting

Add the benefits as text near the sign-in link in the header menu or on the account page, and in the order confirmation email.

Quick test: Wherever you ask shoppers to create an account, do you say what it gives them?

4Keep password rules simple and show them upfront

Show password rules before the shopper types, and prefer a minimum length over a list of character rules.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Create an account

Password••••••••Must contain uppercase, lowercase, a number and a symbol
Create account
The rules appear only after a failed attempt, and they're the kind people forget an hour later.

✓ Do this

9:41

Create an account

Password••••••••••

✓ At least 8 characters

Create account
One simple rule, shown from the start, ticked off as the shopper types.

Why it matters

Complex password rules ("one capital, one symbol, no repeats") revealed only after a failed attempt are a common reason sign-ups fail. Long passwords are more secure than complicated short ones anyway.

How to do it

  • Require a reasonable minimum length rather than character mixes.
  • Show the requirements next to the field before typing, and tick them off as they're met.
  • Allow password managers to fill and generate passwords (don't block paste).
  • Better still, offer passwordless sign-in with a one-time code or link.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify's current customer accounts are passwordless (a code by email), which avoids this problem. Legacy accounts use passwords.

Quick test: Are password rules simple, shown before typing, and compatible with password managers?

5Let shoppers show the password they're typing

Let shoppers see the password they're typing. It prevents typos, especially on phones.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41
Password••••••••••••

Typed on a phone keyboard. Was there a typo?

Create account

qwertyuiop

asdfghjkl

⇧zxcvbnm⌫

123go

Dots only. On a small keyboard a typo is likely, and shoppers find out the next time they try to sign in.

✓ Do this

9:41
Passwordsunny-garden-42 Hide
Create account

qwertyuiop

asdfghjkl

⇧zxcvbnm⌫

123go

A Show/Hide button in the field. Shoppers can check what they typed before submitting.

Why it matters

Typing a password on a phone keyboard, blind, leads to typos, failed sign-ins and resets. A "Show" toggle lets shoppers check what they typed.

How to do it

  • Add a "Show" button inside or next to the password field.
  • Use one password field, not a "confirm password" field; the show option replaces it.
  • Make the toggle a button with a clear label, usable by keyboard and screen reader.

On ShopifyCode

If you use legacy customer accounts with passwords, add the toggle in the theme's login and register templates.

Quick test: Can shoppers reveal the password they're typing?

FAQ

Should I allow guest checkout?

Yes. Forcing account creation is one of the most common reasons shoppers abandon checkout. Offer the account after the order instead.

How do I enable guest checkout on Shopify?

In Settings › Customer accounts, make accounts optional. Shopify's current customer accounts are optional and passwordless by default.

Sources

Alex Peric

Written by Alex Peric

Conversion designer. I design, redesign and build online stores, product pages and landing pages, A/B test them and show what each change earned. CXL certified in Conversion Optimization and Ecommerce Marketing, and a guest speaker on ecommerce UX at NYU School of Professional Studies.

Let's talk

Let's find out why your visitors aren't buying.

Send me the page. On the call I'll tell you what I'd fix first, what it could move, and whether I'm the right person for it.

Book a call