Collection pages and filters · Article 5 of 6

How filters and sorting should behave

Let shoppers pick several options in one filter (any of them) and combine filters (all of them). Explain trade terms, remove redundant filters, show applied filters as removable chips, make the back button undo the last filter, never reset filters without reason, update results live on desktop, mix product types in the default sort, and use plain sort labels.

In this article · 9 tips
  1. When filters behave unexpectedly
  2. 1Let shoppers pick several values in a filter and stack filters together
  3. 2Explain filters that use trade terms
  4. 3Remove filters that repeat the category or each other
  5. 4Show applied filters as a removable list, on phones too
  6. 5Make the back button undo the last filter or sort
  7. 6Never reset filters and sorting without a reason
  8. 7Update the results as filters are applied on desktop
  9. 8Make the default sort mix product types
  10. 9Offer price, rating, best-seller and newest sorting with plain labels
  11. FAQ

In short

  • Filters should behave the way shoppers expect, without them having to think.
  • Showing applied filters, and letting shoppers remove them one by one, prevents confusion.
  • The default sort is the first impression of the collection.

When filters behave unexpectedly

Most filter problems aren't about which filters exist but how they behave: picking a second color removes the first, the back button leaves the site instead of removing a filter, or filters quietly reset. This article covers the behaviour, plus sorting.

1Let shoppers pick several values in a filter and stack filters together

Shoppers often want two colors or two sizes. Let them pick several values in a filter and combine filters.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Color−

Navy12
Black20
Olive6

Tapping Black replaces Navy

12 results

One value at a time. A shopper happy with navy or black has to search twice.

✓ Do this

9:41

Color−

Navy12
Black20
Olive6

Navy or black · 32 results

Tick both, see both. Filters in different groups narrow the results together.

Why it matters

A shopper who wants navy or black should get both. A shopper who wants navy and size M should get only products that are both. Filters that work any other way confuse people.

How to do it

  • Within one filter, show products matching any selected option (navy OR black).
  • Across filters, show products matching all selected filters (navy AND size M).
  • Use checkboxes so multiple selection is obvious.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify's storefront filters work this way.

Quick test: Can shoppers select several options in one filter, and combine filters?

2Explain filters that use trade terms

If a filter uses a trade term, explain it in a line, right where it's used.

All storesSpec-heavy products

✕ Avoid

9:41

Fill power−

5506
6509
8004
"Fill power" with three numbers. Most shoppers don't know if higher is better, or what it means.

✓ Do this

9:41

Fill power ⓘ−

550 · Light warmth6
650 · Warm9
800 · Warmest for its weight4

Higher fill power = more warmth for less weight

A short note and plain labels on each option. The term becomes useful.

Why it matters

"Denier", "GSM", "Shore hardness" or "Vegan-certified" mean nothing to many shoppers. Unexplained, they're either ignored or misused.

How to do it

  • Add a short explanation or info icon to technical filters.
  • Rename filters in plain words where possible ("Thickness" instead of "Denier").

On ShopifyCode

Filter labels come from metafield names; explanations need a small theme change.

Quick test: Are technical filters explained in plain words?

3Remove filters that repeat the category or each other

Remove filters that repeat the category or each other. They add clutter and lead nowhere.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Women › Shoes › Boots

Category−

Boots48

Type−

Boot48

Size+

On the Boots page: a Category filter with only "Boots", and a Type filter with only "Boot".

✓ Do this

9:41

Women › Shoes › Boots

Size−

821
930

Shaft height+

Waterproof+

Only filters that actually split the 48 boots into useful groups.

Why it matters

A "Category: Boots" filter on the Boots page, or a "Material" and a "Fabric" filter with the same values, wastes space and creates dead ends.

How to do it

  • Hide filters that only have one value in the current collection.
  • Merge overlapping filters and values.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify filters show only values present in the collection; review your filter setup for overlaps.

Quick test: Are redundant and overlapping filters removed?

4Show applied filters as a removable list, on phones too

Show the active filters as removable chips above the results, on phones too.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Boots

12 products

Filter (3)Sort

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

"Filter (3)", but which three? To check or remove one, shoppers reopen the filter panel.

✓ Do this

9:41

Boots

12 products

Size 9 ×Waterproof ×Under $200 ×Clear all

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Each active filter is a chip with ×. One tap removes it, "Clear all" resets.

Why it matters

After applying filters, shoppers need to see what's active and remove one without starting over. On phones, filters live in a drawer, so active filters are easy to forget.

How to do it

  • Show applied filters as chips above the results, each with an ×, plus "Clear all".
  • Show them on phones too, above the grid, not only inside the filter drawer.
  • Show the count of active filters on the mobile filter button.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Most Shopify themes show active filters as removable chips.

Quick test: Are applied filters shown as removable chips on desktop and phones?

5Make the back button undo the last filter or sort

The browser's back button should undo the last filter, not throw the shopper off the page.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Boots

12 products

Size 9Waterproof

Back → leaves the page. All filters lost.

Shoppers press back to undo a filter and land on the previous page with everything reset.

✓ Do this

9:41

Boots

21 products

Size 9

Back → removed "Waterproof"

Each filter change is a step in history, so back removes the last one, as shoppers expect.

Why it matters

Shoppers use the back button to undo. If it takes them off the collection entirely, they lose all their filters and their place.

How to do it

  • Update the URL with each filter or sort change so back undoes the last one.
  • Make sure back from a product returns to the filtered list.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify filters update the URL, so back works in most themes.

Quick test: Does the back button undo the last filter change?

6Never reset filters and sorting without a reason

Filters and sort should stay put through pages, load more and returning from a product.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Page 2

Boots

48 products

Filters reset to all 48 boots on page 2

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Shoppers go to page 2 and the filters are gone. They start again or give up.

✓ Do this

9:41

Page 2

Boots

12 products

Size 9WaterproofPrice ↑

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Same filters, same sort, page after page and after every visit to a product.

Why it matters

Filters that reset when shoppers return from a product, change page, or load more force them to set everything again.

How to do it

  • Keep filters and sorting across pagination, load more and returning from products.
  • Reset them only on a new search or a different collection.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify keeps filters in the URL; check load-more and app-based filters.

Quick test: Do filters stay set when shoppers page through results or come back from a product?

7Update the results as filters are applied on desktop

On desktop, update the results as each filter is picked. An "Apply" button hides what each choice does.

All stores

✕ Avoid

Size−

930

Color−

Black20
Apply filters

48 products

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Chelsea boot

★★★★★ 4.8 (340)

$165

Nothing changes until "Apply". Shoppers don't know which choice emptied the results.

✓ Do this

Size−

930

Color−

Black12

12 products · updated

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Chelsea boot

★★★★★ 4.8 (340)

$165

Results and counts update right after each tick, with a brief loading state.

Why it matters

On desktop, seeing the results change immediately helps shoppers understand each filter's effect. An "Apply" button that has to be pressed after every choice slows them down.

How to do it

  • On desktop, update results right after each filter choice, with a short loading state.
  • On phones, update the result count live inside the filter drawer and apply with a "Show results" button (see mobile filters).

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify themes update results as filters change on desktop.

Quick test: Do desktop results update immediately when a filter is chosen?

8Make the default sort mix product types

Make the default order mix product types, so the first screen shows the range.

Big catalogs

✕ Avoid

9:41

Men's clothing

300 products

Basic tee, black

$24

Basic tee, charcoal

$24

Basic tee, blue

$24

Basic tee, slate

$24

The first screen is four of the same T-shirt. Shoppers assume that's all the store sells.

✓ Do this

9:41

Men's clothing

300 products

Shell jacket

$240

Linen shirt

$68

Ridge boot

$189

Day bag

$95

Best sellers from different types first: a jacket, a shirt, boots and a bag.

Why it matters

A default order that shows 20 of the same kind of product (all the black T-shirts first) gives a narrow first impression of a varied collection.

How to do it

  • Use a default order that mixes product types, best sellers and new items near the top.
  • Hand-order the first row or two of key collections.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Set each collection's sort order in the admin: Best selling, or Manual for hand-picked order.

Quick test: Does the default sort show a varied mix at the top?

9Offer price, rating, best-seller and newest sorting with plain labels

Offer the sorts shoppers use, with plain labels: best selling, newest, price and top rated.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Boots

48 products

Sort: Featured▾

Alphabetically, A–Z

Alphabetically, Z–A

Date, old to new

Relevance

Alphabetical and "Date, old to new": sorts nobody needs, and no top rated.

✓ Do this

9:41

Boots

48 products

Sort: Best selling▾

Best selling

Newest

Price: low to high

Price: high to low

Top rated

The five sorts shoppers actually use, in plain words.

Why it matters

Shoppers expect to sort by price, popularity, newness and rating. Labels like "Price ascending" are less clear than "Price: low to high". Rating sorts that ignore the number of reviews put a single 5-star review above hundreds of 4.8s.

How to do it

  • Offer: Featured, Best selling, Newest, Price: low to high, Price: high to low, and Top rated if you can.
  • Show the current sort in the sort control.
  • Sort by rating using both the average and the number of reviews.

On ShopifyBuilt in

Shopify includes Featured, Best selling, Alphabetical, Price and Date sorts; labels can be edited in the theme's language settings. Top rated needs an app.

Quick test: Are price, popularity, newest and rating sorts offered with plain labels?

FAQ

Should filters use AND or OR?

OR within a filter (navy or black), AND across filters (navy and size M). That's what shoppers expect.

What sort options should an online store have?

Featured, Best selling, Newest, Price: low to high, Price: high to low, and Top rated if you can.

Sources

Alex Peric

Written by Alex Peric

Conversion designer. I design, redesign and build online stores, product pages and landing pages, A/B test them and show what each change earned. CXL certified in Conversion Optimization and Ecommerce Marketing, and a guest speaker on ecommerce UX at NYU School of Professional Studies.

Let's talk

Let's find out why your visitors aren't buying.

Send me the page. On the call I'll tell you what I'd fix first, what it could move, and whether I'm the right person for it.

Book a call