Product page · Article 8 of 10

Product reviews: how to collect, show and sort them

Show the rating and review count at the top of the page, linked to the reviews. Let anyone write a review without an account, ask for photos, and show them as a gallery. Add a rating breakdown that filters, sort by relevance with options for lowest, newest and most helpful, let shoppers search reviews by topic, and reply to negative reviews.

In this article · 12 tips
  1. Why reviews matter, and what shoppers do with them
  2. 1Show the rating and review count at the top, linked to the reviews
  3. 2Let anyone write a review, with no account needed
  4. 3Ask reviewers only for details that help other shoppers
  5. 4Collect photo reviews and show them in a row above the reviews
  6. 5Show a rating breakdown, and let each star row filter the reviews
  7. 6Show a handful of reviews first, then "Load more"
  8. 7Default to a mixed "most relevant" order, and let shoppers sort by lowest, newest and most helpful
  9. 8Let shoppers search or filter reviews by topic, variant and verified purchase
  10. 9Show a few clear sub-ratings and the reviewer details that matter
  11. 10Ask for a review title, and show a good example
  12. 11Answer critical reviews in public
  13. 12Show all reviews honestly, and don't make the page depend on reviews alone
  14. FAQ

In short

  • Reviews answer the question shoppers trust you least on: "is it really good?".
  • Negative reviews help shoppers judge whether a product's flaws matter to them. Hiding them, or making them hard to find, makes everything look less credible.
  • Photo reviews are some of the most persuasive content on a product page.
  • Faking reviews or suppressing bad ones is illegal in many markets, including under the FTC's 2024 rule in the US.

Why reviews matter, and what shoppers do with them

Shoppers read reviews to check what you can't tell them believably yourself: whether the product lasts, fits, works as described, and whether its flaws matter to them. Many go straight to the lowest ratings to see the worst case.

So reviews need to be easy to find, easy to scan, and easy to filter for the shopper's own situation. The tips below cover all three, plus how to get more reviews in the first place.

1Show the rating and review count at the top, linked to the reviews

The star rating near the name is one of the first things shoppers check. Make it a link to the reviews.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Studio headphones

$249

↓ Reviews at the bottom of the page

No rating near the name. Shoppers have to scroll to the bottom to learn whether it's any good.

✓ Do this

9:41

Studio headphones

★★★★★ 4.6 (1,284 reviews)

Tap to read

$249

Stars, the average and the review count under the name, linking straight to the reviews.

Why it matters

The star rating near the product name is one of the first things shoppers check. It's even more useful when it's clickable: one tap jumps to the reviews, without scrolling past everything.

How to do it

  • Show the average rating (stars plus number, like 4.6) and the number of reviews right under the product name.
  • Make the whole rating a link that jumps to the review section.
  • Show it even when there are few reviews, and invite the first review when there are none.
  • Use product review structured data so the rating can appear in Google results.

On ShopifyApp

Review apps add a star-rating block for under the title; place it in the product information section. Most apps also add the rating structured data.

Quick test: Is the rating with the review count shown under the product name, linking to the reviews?

2Let anyone write a review, with no account needed

The fewer steps between a happy customer and a review, the more reviews you get.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Write a review

Emailyou@email.com
Password••••••••
Sign in to review
"Sign in to review". Most happy customers won't create an account just for this.

✓ Do this

9:41

How was your skillet?

★★★★★ 5

Titlee.g. Heats evenly, worth the price
Post review
One tap from the email: stars, a title, a few words. Verified buyers marked automatically.

Why it matters

The fewer steps between a happy customer and a published review, the more reviews you get. Requiring an account, a password, or a login link turns many would-be reviewers away.

How to do it

  • Let customers write a review straight from the review request email, without signing in.
  • Show a "Write a review" button on every product page.
  • Mark reviews from verified buyers, so open reviewing doesn't cost credibility.

On ShopifyApp

Most review apps send review request emails after delivery and let customers review without an account. Set the request timing to after delivery, not after purchase.

Quick test: Can customers write a review without creating or signing in to an account?

3Ask reviewers only for details that help other shoppers

Ask reviewers only for details that help other shoppers decide.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Write a review

Age range
Income
Where did you hear about us?
Your review
Questions for the marketing team, not for shoppers. Fewer people finish.

✓ Do this

9:41

Write a review

★★★★☆ 4

Your review
Usual sizeM
Height178 cm
Short, plus the one or two details that help others (size and height for clothing).

Why it matters

Every extra field in a review form makes fewer people finish it. But some details make reviews more useful: a reviewer's size and fit for clothing, skin type for skin care, how long they've used it.

How to do it

  • Keep the form short: rating, title, text, optional photo.
  • Add one or two product-specific details only where they help others decide ("Usual size", "Skin type", "Used for").
  • Make personal details optional, and don't ask for anything you won't show.

On ShopifyApp

Review apps let you add custom questions per product type. Add only the ones that help shoppers compare.

Quick test: Does the review form ask only for details that help other shoppers?

4Collect photo reviews and show them in a row above the reviews

Customer photos are some of the most persuasive content on the page. Put them first in the reviews.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reviews (312)

Great shoes, true to size.

★★★★★ Ana

Comfortable from day one.

★★★★★ Ben
Photos only appear inside individual reviews, if you scroll to them.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reviews (312)

Customer photos

+64

Great shoes, true to size.

★★★★★ Ana · Verified
A row of customer photos at the top. Tapping one opens the review it came with.

Why it matters

Customer photos show the product in real life, and shoppers look for them. Scattered inside individual reviews, they're easy to miss; as a gallery at the top, they're one of the first things shoppers see.

How to do it

  • Ask for a photo in the review request, and make uploading easy on a phone.
  • Show all customer photos as a row or grid at the top of the reviews.
  • Let shoppers tap a photo to read the review it came with, and swipe through the rest.
  • Consider a small incentive for photo reviews, disclosed openly, that doesn't depend on the rating.

On ShopifyApp

Choose a review app that supports photo and video reviews and a photo gallery at the top of the review section.

Quick test: Are customer photos shown as a gallery at the top of the reviews, linked to their reviews?

5Show a rating breakdown, and let each star row filter the reviews

Shoppers want to see the spread of ratings, and to read just the bad ones.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reviews

★★★★☆ 4.3 (412)

…

Most recent first
Only the average. 4.3 could mean steady fours or a worrying pile of ones.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reviews

★★★★☆ 4.3 (412)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Tap a row to read only those reviews

A rating breakdown where every row is a filter. Checking the worst case takes one tap.

Why it matters

An average of 4.3 can mean mostly fives with a worrying number of ones, or a steady run of fours. The breakdown shows which, and letting shoppers tap "1 star" to read only those reviews is how many of them check the worst case.

How to do it

  • Show a bar chart of how many reviews each star rating has, at the top of the reviews.
  • Make each row clickable to filter the reviews to that rating.
  • Show the active filter clearly, with a way to clear it.

On ShopifyApp

Most review apps show a rating breakdown; check that the rows work as filters.

Quick test: Is there a rating breakdown, and does tapping a star row filter the reviews?

6Show a handful of reviews first, then "Load more"

Show several reviews first, then load more in place.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reviews

Love it!

★★★★★

See all 312 reviews ›

One review, then a link to a separate page. Thin at first glance, and a detour to read more.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reviews

Warm and light.

★★★★★

Runs a bit small.

★★★★☆

Zip broke after a month.

★★☆☆☆
Load more reviews
A handful of full reviews, mixed ratings, and "Load more" without leaving the page.

Why it matters

Showing only one or two reviews looks thin and makes shoppers click to see more; showing fifty pushes everything else off the page. A few full reviews, then a button to load more, gives a fair picture without a wall of text.

How to do it

  • Show several reviews by default, in full (or with a short "Read more" for long ones).
  • Add a "Load more reviews" button that adds more in place, rather than pagination that jumps the page.
  • Keep the filter and sort controls visible above the list.

On ShopifyApp

Set how many reviews show by default in your review app's display settings.

Quick test: Does the review section show several reviews first, with "Load more" in place?

7Default to a mixed "most relevant" order, and let shoppers sort by lowest, newest and most helpful

Default to a fair mix, and let shoppers sort by lowest, newest and most helpful.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reviews

Sorted by: Highest rating (fixed)

Perfect!

★★★★★

Amazing!

★★★★★
Highest first, no other option. It looks like cherry-picking.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reviews

Sort:

Most relevant▾
Most helpfulNewestLowest rating

Detailed review with pros and cons…

★★★★☆ · 38 found helpful
A mixed default that favors detailed reviews, with sort options in plain sight.

Why it matters

Sorting by newest shows whatever came in last week; sorting by highest looks like cherry-picking. A relevance order that mixes ratings, recent reviews and helpful ones with detail gives a fair first impression. Shoppers who want something else should find sorting easily.

How to do it

  • Default to a relevance sort that mixes positive and critical reviews, favouring detailed and recent ones.
  • Offer sorting by most recent, lowest rating, highest rating and most helpful.
  • Put the sort control where shoppers see it, at the top of the list, not hidden in a menu.
  • Let shoppers mark reviews as helpful.

On ShopifyApp

Check your review app's default sort setting and whether it offers "most helpful" and "lowest rating".

Quick test: Is the default review order mixed, with easy sorting by lowest, newest and most helpful?

8Let shoppers search or filter reviews by topic, variant and verified purchase

With many reviews, shoppers want the ones about their concern.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reviews (1,284)

…

…

Page 1 of 257

1,284 reviews and no way to find the ones about battery life.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reviews (1,284)

Search reviews
Battery (212)Comfort (180)With photosVerified
Search, topic chips and filters for photos and verified buyers.

Why it matters

With dozens of reviews, shoppers want the ones about their concern: "fit", "battery", "smell", or the color they're buying. Searching or filtering by topic gets them there without reading everything.

How to do it

  • Offer review search, and show common topics as tappable chips ("Fit", "Comfort", "Battery life").
  • Let shoppers filter to reviews with photos, verified buyers, and a specific variant.
  • Highlight the search term in matching reviews.

On ShopifyApp

Some review apps generate topic chips and review search automatically; check for it when choosing one.

Quick test: Can shoppers search or filter reviews by topic, variant, photos and verified purchase?

9Show a few clear sub-ratings and the reviewer details that matter

For some products, "runs small" matters more than the stars.

Apparel & beautyAll stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Reviews

★★★★☆ 4.4 (220)

Nice boots but…

★★★★☆
Only stars. Shoppers read dozens of reviews to work out the fit.

✓ Do this

9:41

Reviews

★★★★☆ 4.4 (220)

Fit: runs half a size small

Comfort

Warmth

A few clear sub-ratings, like fit and comfort, at the top.

Why it matters

For some products, an overall rating isn't enough: "Runs small", "Very comfortable but not warm". A few sub-ratings (fit, comfort, value) and reviewer details (usual size, height, skin type) let shoppers find reviews from people like them.

How to do it

  • Add two or three sub-ratings that matter for the product type, with plain labels ("Fit: runs small – true to size – runs large").
  • Show the reviewer details you collected next to each review.
  • Show a summary of the sub-ratings at the top.

On ShopifyApp

Review apps that support custom questions can show sub-ratings and reviewer details; set them up per product type.

Quick test: Are there a few clear sub-ratings and relevant reviewer details on reviews?

10Ask for a review title, and show a good example

Titles make reviews scannable. Ask for one, and show what a useful title looks like.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Great!

★★★★★

Ok

★★★☆☆

Love

★★★★★
"Great!", "Ok", "Love". The list says nothing until each review is opened.

✓ Do this

9:41

Warm enough for winter commutes

★★★★★

Runs small, order a size up

★★★☆☆

Light and packs down tiny

★★★★★
Specific titles. Shoppers scan them and read the ones that match their worry.

Why it matters

Titles make a list of reviews scannable: shoppers read the titles and open the ones that match their concern. "Great!" says nothing; "Warm enough for winter commutes" says a lot.

How to do it

  • Ask for a title in the review form.
  • Show an example of a useful title in the field ("e.g. Comfortable for long walks, runs half a size small").
  • Show titles in bold above each review.

On ShopifyApp

Most review apps support titles; turn them on and edit the field's example text.

Quick test: Do reviews have titles, with an example of a useful one in the form?

11Answer critical reviews in public

A helpful public reply to a bad review builds more trust than a spotless rating.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Strap broke after two weeks. Very disappointed.

★☆☆☆☆ Lee
A one-star review with no reply. It looks like nobody's listening.

✓ Do this

9:41

Strap broke after two weeks. Very disappointed.

★☆☆☆☆ Lee

Sorry, Lee. That's covered by our 2-year warranty: we've emailed you a free replacement.

Reply from the store
A specific, helpful reply. Shoppers see what happens when something goes wrong.

Why it matters

A negative review with a helpful public reply shows shoppers what happens when something goes wrong, and that matters more to them than a spotless rating. Silence suggests nobody's listening.

How to do it

  • Reply to negative and mixed reviews, publicly, within a few days.
  • Be specific and helpful: acknowledge the problem, explain the fix or the policy, offer to help.
  • Never argue, and never ask the reviewer to delete the review.
  • Use recurring complaints to fix the product page (a sizing note, a better photo).

On ShopifyApp

Review apps let you reply publicly from the admin. Set up a notification for low ratings.

Quick test: Do negative reviews get a helpful public reply from the store?

12Show all reviews honestly, and don't make the page depend on reviews alone

Show every genuine review. Hiding bad ones is a trust problem and, in the US, a legal one.

All storesSmall catalogs

✕ Avoid

9:41

★★★★★ 5 (48)

Perfect

★★★★★

Perfect

★★★★★

Only 4–5★ reviews are published

A perfect 5.0. Shoppers find it hard to believe, and suppressing negative reviews is banned under the FTC's 2024 rule.

✓ Do this

9:41

★★★★★ 4.6 (52)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Good, but the lid is fiddly

★★★☆☆ · Verified
A believable mix. The critical reviews make the positive ones credible.

Why it matters

Shoppers trust a mix of ratings more than a perfect five. Hiding or filtering out bad reviews, or inventing good ones, is both a trust problem and a legal one: the FTC's 2024 rule bans fake reviews and suppressing negative ones. For small brands with few reviews, the rest of the page has to carry the trust.

How to do it

  • Publish all genuine reviews, positive and negative, unless they break clear content rules (abuse, personal data, off-topic). Apply those rules evenly.
  • Disclose any incentive for reviews, and don't make incentives depend on a positive rating.
  • If you have few reviews, lean on other proof: guarantees, clear photos, specs, press, how the product is made.
  • Import reviews from other channels (like marketplaces) only if your review tool shows where they came from.

On ShopifyApp

Check your review app's moderation settings: auto-publish should apply to all ratings, not only four and five stars.

Quick test: Are all genuine reviews published, with incentives disclosed and other proof where reviews are few?

FAQ

Where should reviews go on a product page?

The rating and count go under the product name, linked to the full reviews, which usually sit after the description and specs.

Should I show negative reviews?

Yes. They make the positive ones believable, help shoppers judge whether a flaw matters to them, and suppressing them is illegal in the US under the FTC's 2024 rule.

Which Shopify review app should I use?

Pick one that offers photo reviews, a photo gallery, filters and sorting, review search, structured data, and fast loading. Check the app's display on a phone before you commit.

How do I get more product reviews?

Send a review request after delivery with a one-tap way to rate, no account needed, and ask for a photo. Follow up once.

Sources

Alex Peric

Written by Alex Peric

Conversion designer. I design, redesign and build online stores, product pages and landing pages, A/B test them and show what each change earned. CXL certified in Conversion Optimization and Ecommerce Marketing, and a guest speaker on ecommerce UX at NYU School of Professional Studies.

Let's talk

Let's find out why your visitors aren't buying.

Send me the page. On the call I'll tell you what I'd fix first, what it could move, and whether I'm the right person for it.

Book a call