Collection pages and filters · Article 3 of 6

Swatches, quick view, compare and other product card extras

Show color swatches on cards and switch the photo when one is picked. Let guests save to a wishlist, offer compare for spec-heavy products with complete, explained tables, use quick view mainly on desktop, add quick add for cheap repeat items, keep badges rare, and mark products already in the cart.

In this article · 8 tips
  1. Extras that earn their place
  2. 1Show color swatches on cards and switch the photo when one is picked
  3. 2Let guests save to a wishlist without an account
  4. 3Offer compare for spec-heavy products
  5. 4Make comparison tables easy to scan, complete, and explained
  6. 5Quick view: useful on desktop for visual products, risky on phones
  7. 6Offer quick add to cart for cheap and repeat-purchase items
  8. 7Use badges sparingly, only for facts that change the choice
  9. 8Mark products that are already in the cart
  10. FAQ

In short

  • Extras help when they save a trip to the product page. Otherwise they're clutter.
  • Comparison only works when the data is complete and understandable.
  • Badges lose their meaning when every product has one.

Extras that earn their place

Product cards can do more than link to a product: show colors, save for later, compare, preview, add to cart. Each extra adds something to every card in the grid, so each one has to be worth it.

1Show color swatches on cards and switch the photo when one is picked

Show color swatches on the card and switch the photo when one is tapped.

Apparel & beautyHome & furniture

✕ Avoid

9:41

Mugs

9 products

Stoneware mug

4 colors

$17

Espresso cup

2 colors

$14

"4 colors" as text. Shoppers have to open the product to see what the colors are.

✓ Do this

9:41

Mugs

9 products

Stoneware mug

$17

Espresso cup

$14

Real swatches on the card. Tapping blue switches the photo to the blue mug.

Why it matters

Shoppers choose visual products by color. Swatches on cards show the options without opening the product; switching the photo when one is tapped shows the actual color.

How to do it

  • Show swatches for every color on the card (or the first few plus "+3").
  • Change the card photo when a swatch is hovered or tapped.
  • Make swatches big enough to tap on phones, or show a color count there.

On ShopifyTheme setting

Recent Shopify themes can show color swatches on product cards from your variant options; older themes need an app.

Quick test: Do cards show color swatches that switch the photo?

2Let guests save to a wishlist without an account

Let anyone save a product with a heart, no account needed. Ask them to sign in later, to keep the list.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Boots

48 products

♡

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

♡

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Sign in to save items

Sign in

Create account

Tapping the heart opens a sign-in wall. Most shoppers close it and never save anything.

✓ Do this

9:41

Saved to your wishlist

Boots

48 products

♥

Ridge boot

$189

♡

Summit boot

$210

Sign in any time to keep your list across devices

One tap saves it. Signing in is offered later, as a way to keep the list.

Why it matters

Shoppers shortlist while browsing. Requiring an account to save a product stops most of them.

How to do it

  • Add a heart icon to cards that saves without signing in.
  • Show a count in the header and a wishlist page.
  • Offer to save the list to an account later.

On ShopifyApp

Shopify has no built-in wishlist; pick a wishlist app that supports guests.

Quick test: Can guests save products from the grid without an account?

3Offer compare for spec-heavy products

For products chosen on specs, let shoppers tick a few and compare them side by side.

Spec-heavy products

✕ Avoid

Air purifiers

14 products

Pure 300

$249

Pure 500

$349

Mini 100

$129

Max 700

$499

No compare. Shoppers open four tabs and write notes.

No way to compare. Shoppers juggle tabs, or leave for a site that compares for them.

✓ Do this

Air purifiers

14 products

Pure 300

$249

Compare

Pure 500

$349

Compare

Mini 100

$129

Compare

Max 700

$499

Compare

2 selected

Compare 2 products
A Compare box on each card and a bar that appears once two are ticked.

Why it matters

For electronics, appliances and tools, shoppers narrow down to a few products and compare specs. Without a compare feature, they open tabs and switch back and forth.

How to do it

  • Add a "Compare" checkbox to cards in spec-heavy categories.
  • Show a compare bar with selected products and a "Compare now" button.
  • Allow comparing at least three or four products.

On ShopifyApp

Product comparison needs an app or custom section using metafields.

Quick test: Can shoppers compare spec-heavy products side by side?

4Make comparison tables easy to scan, complete, and explained

In a comparison table, highlight what's different and let shoppers hide what's the same.

Spec-heavy products

✕ Avoid

Pure 300Pure 500Max 700Room size40 m²65 m²90 m²FilterHEPA 13HEPA 13HEPA 13Voltage120 V120 V120 VNoise24 dB28 dB31 dBColorWhiteWhiteWhiteCADR210330450
Every row looks the same, and half of them are identical. The differences are buried.

✓ Do this

Hide rows that are the same
Pure 300Pure 500Max 700Room size40 m²65 m²90 m²Noise24 dB28 dB31 dBClean air rate ⓘ210330450Price$249$349$499
Only the rows that differ, highlighted, with an explanation for the trade term.

Why it matters

A comparison table with gaps, inconsistent units and unexplained specs doesn't help anyone decide.

How to do it

  • Highlight differences, and let shoppers hide rows where products are the same.
  • Make sure every product has every compared value; fill gaps in your data.
  • Explain technical specs with short notes or tooltips (see explained specs).
  • Keep product names and photos visible while scrolling the table.

On ShopifyCode

Clean, consistent metafields are what make comparison tables work.

Quick test: Are comparison tables complete, consistent and easy to scan?

5Quick view: useful on desktop for visual products, risky on phones

Quick view can help on desktop for products chosen by look. On phones it's usually a cramped copy of the product page.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Boots

48 products

Ridge boot · $189

7891011
Add to cart

✕

A small pop-up on a phone: tiny photo, no reviews, no details. Shoppers close it and open the page anyway.

✓ Do this

Boots

48 products

Ridge boot

$189 · ★ 4.7 (212)

78910
Add to cart

See full details ›

On desktop: large photo, sizes, Add to cart and a link to the full page. On phones, cards go straight to the product.

Why it matters

A quick view pop-up lets desktop shoppers see more photos and options without leaving the grid. On phones, it's a cramped full-screen layer that's easy to confuse with the product page.

How to do it

  • Offer quick view on desktop for visual products, with large photos, options and a link to the full page.
  • Skip it on phones, or make it clearly a preview with a prominent "View full details".
  • Don't let quick view replace the product page for complex products.

On ShopifyTheme setting

Some themes have quick view built in; others use quick add instead.

Quick test: Is quick view used only where it helps, with a clear link to the full product?

6Offer quick add to cart for cheap and repeat-purchase items

For simple, cheap or repeat items, let shoppers add to cart straight from the card.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Coffee

16 products

House blend 250 g

$14

Choose options

Decaf 250 g

$15

Choose options
"Choose options" on a product with no options. Regulars restocking coffee have to open each page.

✓ Do this

9:41

Added: House blend

Coffee

16 products

House blend 250 g

$14

+ Add

Decaf 250 g

$15

+ Add
"+ Add" on the card, with a short confirmation. Restocking takes seconds.

Why it matters

For a $6 refill or a pack of socks bought every month, opening the product page is unnecessary. Quick add saves the trip.

How to do it

  • Add a quick-add button for products with no options or one simple option.
  • For products with sizes or colors, open a small option picker first.
  • Confirm the add clearly (see after Add to cart).

On ShopifyTheme setting

Many Shopify themes have a "Quick add" setting on the product grid.

Quick test: Can shoppers add cheap, simple products straight from the grid?

7Use badges sparingly, only for facts that change the choice

Use one badge per card at most, and only for facts that change the choice.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41

Boots

48 products

NEWHOT-20%ECO

Ridge boot

$189

BESTSELLERTRENDINGLIMITED

Summit boot

$210

Every card shouts. With five badges each, none of them means anything.

✓ Do this

9:41

Boots

48 products

−20%

Ridge boot

$151 $189

Best seller

Summit boot

$210

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

A single badge, only where it's true and useful: a real discount or a real best seller.

Why it matters

"New", "Bestseller", "Eco", "-20%", "Staff pick" all on one card is noise. Badges help when they're rare and mean something.

How to do it

  • Limit badges to one per card and to a few types across the store.
  • Use them for facts shoppers care about: sale, new, low stock (if real), a meaningful certification.
  • Never use fake scarcity badges.

On ShopifyTheme setting

Shopify themes show sale and sold-out badges; other badges come from tags or apps.

Quick test: Are badges rare, factual and limited to one per card?

8Mark products that are already in the cart

Mark products already in the cart, so shoppers don't add them twice or wonder if they did.

All stores

✕ Avoid

9:41
☰STORE⌕♡🛍2

Boots

48 products

Ridge boot

★★★★★ 4.7 (212)

$189

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Chelsea boot

★★★★★ 4.8 (340)

$165

Trail mid

★★★★☆ 4.4 (58)

$149

Two boots are already in the cart, but the cards look the same. Shoppers add duplicates or check the cart.

✓ Do this

9:41
☰STORE⌕♡🛍2

Boots

48 products

Ridge boot

$189

✓ In your cart

Summit boot

★★★★★ 4.5 (96)

$210

Chelsea boot

★★★★★ 4.8 (340)

$165

A small "In your cart" label on the card. No guessing, no duplicates.

Why it matters

Shoppers who added something earlier lose track. A small "In cart" note prevents duplicates and reminds them what they've chosen.

How to do it

  • Show an "In your cart" label on cards of products already added.
  • Keep it subtle.

On ShopifyCode

Needs a small theme change that reads the cart.

Quick test: Do cards show which products are already in the cart?

FAQ

Is quick view good for conversion?

On desktop, for visual products, it can help. On phones it often confuses. Quick add is usually better for simple products.

Do I need a wishlist on my store?

If shoppers often compare and come back later, yes, and it must work for guests.

Sources

Alex Peric

Written by Alex Peric

Conversion designer. I design, redesign and build online stores, product pages and landing pages, A/B test them and show what each change earned. CXL certified in Conversion Optimization and Ecommerce Marketing, and a guest speaker on ecommerce UX at NYU School of Professional Studies.

Let's talk

Let's find out why your visitors aren't buying.

Send me the page. On the call I'll tell you what I'd fix first, what it could move, and whether I'm the right person for it.

Book a call